| American League | RBIs |
|---|
| Chris Shanahan - Twins | 15 |
| Ryan Harvey - Indians | 8 |
| Jared Notargiacomo - Indians | 8 |
| Jim Barry - Yankees | 7 |
| Francisco Brito - Indians | 7 |
| Joe Weidenbach - Yankees | 7 |
| Orlando Aponte - Red Sox | 6 |
| Bruce Brown - Yankees | 6 |
| Mike Doherty - Athletics | 6 |
| Izhar Falcon - Twins | 6 |
| George Flanders - White Sox | 6 |
| Ryan Gaudet - Orioles | 6 |
| Dan Hickey - Twins | 6 |
| Brian Lavoie - Twins | 6 |
| Steve Walsh - Red Sox | 6 |
| Mike Belair - Orioles | 5 |
| Tom Burgess - Twins | 5 |
| Tom Klemm - Athletics | 5 |
| Jamie MacLauchlan - Athletics | 5 |
| Matt Mastas - Athletics | 5 |
| Ryan Pearson - Athletics | 5 |
| Brian Shea - Indians | 5 |
| Dan Shea - Indians | 5 |
| Brad Smith - Athletics | 5 |
| Kevin Smith - White Sox | 5 |
| Tim Sullivan - White Sox | 5 |
| Chris Augeri - Yankees | 4 |
| Buddy Baribeault - Twins | 4 |
| Rob Guarino - Orioles | 4 |
| Noel Hernandez - Red Sox | 4 |
| Pete Hudson - Yankees | 4 |
| Derrick Koes - Indians | 4 |
| Nestor Ramirez - Yankees | 4 |
| Steve Silva - Athletics | 4 |
| Kevin Spitz - Indians | 4 |
| Bill Brooks - Indians | 3 |
| David Clapp - Yankees | 3 |
| Ian Davis - Orioles | 3 |
| Sam Descoteaux - White Sox | 3 |
| Chris Fantasia - Orioles | 3 |
| David Fieldsend - Orioles | 3 |
| Mike Gauthier - Athletics | 3 |
| Adam McFadden - Indians | 3 |
| Lance Mosher - Yankees | 3 |
| Louie Nocca - Twins | 3 |
| Sam Oliver - White Sox | 3 |
| Ken Perron - Twins | 3 |
| Jason Tevepaugh - Red Sox | 3 |
| Tim Whalen - Indians | 3 |
| Joe Beitz - White Sox | 2 |
| Joe Braga - Athletics | 2 |
| Ismael Brito - Indians | 2 |
| Rich Callahan - Twins | 2 |
| Paul Firicano - Indians | 2 |
| Mike Garon - Orioles | 2 |
| Steven Hannigan - Orioles | 2 |
| Frank Kavalowskas - Red Sox | 2 |
| Nick LaBello - Athletics | 2 |
| Gary Lacroix - White Sox | 2 |
| Ricky Larochelle - Yankees | 2 |
| Ben Lugo - Red Sox | 2 |
| Jim Lyons - Red Sox | 2 |
| Bryan McIntire - Athletics | 2 |
| John O'Neill - Red Sox | 2 |
| Felix Ramirez - White Sox | 2 |
| Jeff Richardson - Indians | 2 |
| Mark Robinson - White Sox | 2 |
| Adam Scharff - Twins | 2 |
| Mike Sheehan - Red Sox | 2 |
| Brian Turmenne - White Sox | 2 |
| Chris Velez - Red Sox | 2 |
| Dale Wiggins - Indians | 2 |
| Dave Bernardini - Yankees | 1 |
| Chris Bleau - Orioles | 1 |
| Jeff Buxton - Twins | 1 |
| Vinny Cimmino - Orioles | 1 |
| Jay Clermont - Yankees | 1 |
| Erick Collazo - White Sox | 1 |
| Steven Consalvi - Twins | 1 |
| John Hernandez - Orioles | 1 |
| Mark Magoon - Athletics | 1 |
| Mark Nichols - Red Sox | 1 |
| Jack O'Neill - Red Sox | 1 |
| Octavio Rodriguez - Athletics | 1 |
| Mickey Ryan - Red Sox | 1 |
| Sokpheap Som - Indians | 1 |
| Ken Wilson - White Sox | 1 |
| Tom Zawisza - Yankees | 1 |